The state of our union is fractured. We’ve moved into camps. Most political conservatives have rallied around the flag of Donald Trump. Liberals and moderates are looking ahead to the mid-term elections, hoping for a check on the policies of our president.
Within my Christian community the camps are clearly defined. Theological conservatives for the most part have embraced Mr. Trump. Fully 82% of white evangelicals voted for him and still think he’s doing a good job. Theological liberals and moderates like me are perplexed how our Christian sisters and brothers come to such different conclusions.
Our polarized society has led people to no longer talk with but rather talking at and about each other. The result is that the narrative of ‘the other’ as an opponent, even an enemy, is reinforced.
What to do? Is there a third way beyond labeling and confrontation?
Recently I participated with a small group of clergy in a meeting with leaders of Immigration and Custom Enforcement (ICE). We had sent a letter asking for a meeting for the purpose of humanizing and better understanding one another.
To be clear I have grave concerns regarding the policies of our current administration towards undocumented immigrants. I also know I have the capacity to view those tasked with enforcing such policies (ICE) as the opposition.
With this in mind we sent the letter asking for a meeting. To our surprise ICE responded quickly welcoming such a meeting. The meeting consisted of two ICE officers (one a senior official) and four clergy: a Rabbi, a Catholic priest, a Pentecostal pastor whose congregation includes recent immigrants and me (an American Baptist pastor).
For an hour we had a civil conversation. The clergy group asked questions regarding ICE priorities and methods. We voiced areas of concern. The ICE officers shared their perspective.
We also got to know the ICE officers as people. My sense was that these two officers, one who had been working in ICE for over twenty years, are people of integrity, trying to enforce policies in as humane a manner as possible.
Let me be clear. I think the policies being enforced are often inhumane. For example, the current policy to separate children from parents at the border, as a means of discouraging immigration, is morally bankrupt https://action.aclu.org/petition/separating-families.
Yet, I think it is unfair to paint all ICE officers with a broad brush stroke. They don’t set the policy. They are tasked with enforcing a policy which I suspect can take a toll on their emotional and spiritual well-being.
For my part I am going to continue advocating for a more humane immigration policy. I will continue to stand with our undocumented neighbors at risk. My faith teaches that I can do no other.
What I won’t do is paint all ICE with a broad brush stroke. I won’t label them. I’ll keep the officers and their families in my prayers, as I surely keep in prayer those arrested and detained and their families.
I’ll work and pray for an immigration system that doesn’t dehumanize those seeking a better future and those tasked with enforcement. I’ll remember that everyone has a story.
Perhaps that is the answer to becoming a more humane and unified society. Moving beyond labels and listening to the stories of others. In listening we discover our common humanity.